We’re a family of Marvel junkies. We can’t seem to get enough superhero stories. You should see the costume bin.
While we’re excited about the new Doomsday movie coming out one week before Christmas Day, we’re also focused on our Catholic faith.
We’re unpacking the Advent wreath, the Nativities (Yes! So many!), lights on the house, blow-up Bumble, and my we-need-to-clean-up-this-living-room-so-family-can-visit ranting. Fun times.
While we start getting into the Advent season, alongside our countdown to Marvel’s Doomsday, I’ve been wondering. Is Marvel Prolife?
Most wouldn’t consider the popular Marvel Cinematic Universe to be Catholic per se, or even Christian, but there are a fair number of prolife themes throughout the fictional multiverse. After all, they’re trying to save the lives of the innocent, and sometimes the not-so-innocent. Get your geek on and let’s unpack a few instances here.
Spoiler Alert: I’m talking about plots and certain details. If you’re catching up on movies you’ve missed, you’ve been warned.
Captain America
Let’s start with a classic hero: Captain Steve Rogers. Steve is a good boy from humble beginnings. Dr. Abraham Erskine chose him for the ultimate soldier not for his stature or strength, but for his character. He jumped on a grenade to save those around him while the rest of the company ran for cover. The dummy grenade was a test he passed with flying colors. It sealed the doctor’s choice.
Later, Dr. Erskine advised Steve to never change who he is after the experiment that grew the scrawny asthmatic into the super soldier we all know and love. With that beginning, Steve has always tried to stand up for the little guy, be a voice for the voiceless, and even spare the lives of offenders on many occasions. He is a soldier, so he’s not strictly no-kill.
In Infinity War, when Vision offered to sacrifice himself, Steve said, “We don’t trade lives.” The man stands for free will (especially in Civil War), saving lives, protecting the innocent, and doing what’s right no matter the cost.
Daredevil
In the case of Matt Murdock, the blind lawyer who secretly fights crime as Daredevil, he’s actually Catholic. He practices his faith, goes to church, and even Confession. Marvel does a good job showing his faith along with his struggle as a crime fighter in and out of the court room.
While he fights brutally throughout the comics and TV series, he won’t take a life. Despite the number of times he’s sparred Wilson Fisk’s life, Fisk still keeps coming back to his old ways, even trying to kill Daredevil. I mean, that’s how comic bad guys just work, right?
Still, Matt holds to his faith and—though it’s a struggle—maintains his virtue. The best part is that even though he struggles and has dark moments, he continues to go to Confession and reset himself. It’s a lesson for us all.
Spider-Man
Similar to Daredevil but without the Catholicism, your friendly neighbor Spider-Man has had some ugly experiences, but he’s always refused to kill. (We’re talking human bad guys. Infinity War’s alien attack doesn’t count.)
Peter Parker’s a classic nerdy kid who gains powers and is faced with choice after choice. In the end, he always seems to choose the right thing, protecting the innocent, being honest, and sparing the bad guys. No matter the platform or Spider-version for Peter Parker, the theme remains.
In No Way Home, there’s a team-up of Spider-Man… Mans? Spider… Men? You get the idea. Tom Holland’s Spider-Man suffers the loss of his Aunt May because of the Green Goblin. Aunt May had just said the famous (and dooming) line, “With great power comes great responsibility.” That line is the catalyst said by each Spider-person’s mentor before death. It drives all the Spider-folks (Spider-guys?) into a life of self-sacrifice and service to the public.
Most heroes would be simply fighting the bad guys, but this is a collection of Spider-Men (I think that’s best). They collectively choose to heal the baddies in No Way Home. While Tom’s character is suffering dark thoughts, the older, wiser Spider (Toby Maguire’s) picks up on this. Aided by Andrew Garfield’s Spider-Man, the two wiser Spiders help Tom’s Spider overcome this and spare Green Goblin in time for him to be healed. This also saves Tom’s Spider-Man from damaging his no-kill record… a thing that would drastically change his character.
Vision
Vision was initially designed by Tony Stark and Bruce Banner with the hopes of creating something better to protect the world. When their plan failed, Ultron was created. Ultron was filled with judgment, malice, and ego. He instantly made plans to wipe out humanity. While he’s trying to create a more human body for himself in a device called the Cradle, the Avengers steal the Cradle and get it to Tony and Bruce. The two geniuses finish the work by adding Jarvis’s programming, an AI designed by Tony with strict safety protocols and much less ego.
Phew! It’s not easy summing up a movie’s plot in a few sentences.
Vision comes to life with a sudden burst, but before the Avengers can react, he pauses. He speaks peacefully, thinking about his own existence. He even apologizes for his outburst. He tells them they need to stop Ultron to save innocent people. Then he does something that shocks them all. He picks up Thor’s hammer like it’s a paperweight. (Only those worthy can pick up the hammer. Keep up.)
Later, with Ultron defeated, Vision must destroy him… But wait, you say, that doesn’t sound very prolife. Hang on. Ultron is AI, but that’s more meaningful to Vision that to us. Here’s my speculation.
If you’ve seen VisionQuest, you’ll know that Ultron himself declared that he “couldn’t help that he was copied and saved.” It begs the question, did Vision actually save Ultron after all?
One more for Vis. Let’s go back to Infinity War when Vision chose to give himself up. He knew the stakes and knew his life could save countless if he just let them take what was believed to be his lifeforce, the Mind Stone. (That’s not how life works, but… fantasy world.) He eventually sacrificed himself in an attempt to save half the universe.
Okay, last Vision comment. Vision is constantly trying to understand humanity, but he speaks with such wisdom as one who already understands. He refers to grief as “love persevering.” He recognizes life as beautiful regardless of its usefulness. In this perspective, he claims all life as valuable.
The Fantastic Four
Let’s finish with the family. The entire premise of the most recent Fantastic Four movie (2025) involves the heroes refusing to trade the life of an unborn baby for their entire world.
Sue Storm is pregnant with Rich Reed’s child. The Silver Surfer bears the message that Galactus will soon destroy their world. They immediately try to stop him. Once he knows about Sue’s baby, he wants them to give up their unborn child in order to spare their world. They refuse to give up their child and work to save both their world and their unborn child’s life.
When they get home, the tell the crowd. The people initially demand they give up their son. Sue Storm eventually says, “I will not sacrifice my son for this world, but I will not sacrifice this world for my son.” That seemed to calm the crowd because it was a heartfelt movie line and… plotline. One can only wish a crowd could be swayed so easily.
Ultimately, they find a clever way to send Galactus far away and save both their world and their the life of their newborn, Franklin Benjamin Reed. Later, we see a mother-child bond in action when baby Franklin saves his own mother from death. He actually brings her back to life, but yeah… sci-fi movies. Still, these characters don’t give up on life. With the whole plotline bent on them saving their child before he’s born, it might be the most direct prolife theme in Marvel.
There’s More
There’s lots more to add. Nightcrawler is also Catholic. Tony Stark, aka Ironman, sacrificed himself famously in Endgame. The entire saga from Infinity War to Endgame was about not sacrificing half the lives in the universe to save the rest, then risking everything to get half of life back. Life, in the MCU, is worth fighting for at all stages.
Are you a Marvel fan? Who or what would you add?